Persistency: How to Keep Final Expense Policies on the Books
Writing a final expense policy is only half the job. The other half is making sure it is still in force a year from now, and five years from now, when the family needs it. That is persistency: the share of your policies that stay on the books. It decides whether advances become earned commission, whether renewals keep coming, and whether families actually get paid.
Why persistency matters so much in final expense
Final expense is usually sold with simplified underwriting, and early lapses tend to be higher on these plans. In a Society of Actuaries report on simplified issue, one panelist's company put early-duration lapse rates 41% to 80% higher for simplified issue than for fully underwritten business, and another said the gap is largest in the first two to three years (Society of Actuaries). Those first years are also when most advance chargebacks happen. If you have not read it yet, our article on chargebacks explains how that money comes back out of your pay.
Why policies fall off
In our experience, most lapses trace back to a handful of causes:
- The draft date doesn't line up with when the client's money arrives, so the payment bounces.
- The client didn't fully understand what they bought, or what it costs every month.
- A family member talked them out of it after the agent left.
- Another agent replaced the policy.
- Nobody from the agency ever called again.
Match the draft to the money
Many final expense clients live on Social Security. The Social Security Administration pays most people on the second, third or fourth Wednesday of the month, depending on their birth date. People who started benefits on or before April 30, 1997, or who get both Social Security and SSI, are paid on the 3rd (Social Security Administration).
Many carriers let you set the draft to follow that schedule. American Amicable's agent manual, for example, lists Social Security draft options for the 1st, the 3rd, and the 2nd, 3rd or 4th Wednesday. If a draft is returned, the carrier says it notifies the owner and the writing agent and waits until the next Social Security date to draft again, this time for two months of premium (American Amicable agent manual). Check each carrier's own options before you submit.
Make the delivery count
Go back over the policy with the client once it is issued. Confirm the monthly premium, the draft date, the face amount and who the beneficiary is. If the plan is graded or guaranteed issue, explain again what it pays in the first two years, using the carrier's wording. Encourage the client to tell the beneficiary where the policy is. A client who understands what they bought, and a family who knows about it, is much less likely to cancel it.
Add a second set of eyes
Some states give older policyowners the right to name someone else who also gets lapse notices. Florida, for example, requires insurers to tell applicants about their right to designate a secondary addressee. For many policies on people age 64 or older, the insurer must mail a lapse notice to both the owner and that person before the policy can lapse. Florida's notice rule has exceptions, including many policies paid by automatic bank draft (Florida Statutes 627.4555). Rules differ by state, so check what your state and carrier offer.
Know the grace period and reinstatement rules
A missed payment doesn't always mean a lost policy. Most individual life policies have a grace period. Many states require 30 or 31 days, and many policies are written with 31 days (ALFA International). After a lapse, reinstatement may still be possible. North Carolina, for example, requires individual policies to allow reinstatement within five years of default, with evidence of insurability and payment of overdue premiums with interest (North Carolina General Statutes 58-58-22). Carrier terms and state rules vary, so read the policy before you promise a client anything.
Why owning your book matters here
Persistency work only pays off if the clients are yours. In our view, independent agents who own their book have every reason to service it, because the renewals and the referrals stay with them. Some captive and MLM-style agencies keep tight control of client records, so the agent who wrote the business may not be the one who gets the lapse notice. Before you join any agency, ask who owns the book, who sees pending lapse reports, and how fast you hear about a returned draft.
Takeaway
Persistency is built at the kitchen table and protected with follow-up. Match the draft to the client's income, explain the policy clearly at delivery, offer a secondary addressee where available, and act fast on any missed payment. Results vary by client, carrier and state.
Practical steps
- Ask how and when the client is paid. Set the draft date to match, using the carrier's Social Security options when they're available.
- Confirm the monthly premium out loud. Make sure it fits the client's budget before you submit.
- Do a policy delivery. Review the premium, draft date, face amount, beneficiary and any waiting period.
- Offer a secondary addressee. Use the carrier's form where your state or carrier allows it.
- Watch pending lapse and returned draft notices. Call the same day. Many payment problems can be fixed while the policy is still in its grace period.
- Call at the 30-day, six-month and one-year marks. A short check-in keeps you in touch and is a natural time to ask for referrals.
The bottom line
Policies that stay in force protect families and keep commissions earned. None of this guarantees a policy stays on the books, and results vary, but clear sales, matched draft dates and steady follow-up give every policy a better chance. Always follow each carrier's current rules and your state's requirements.
Ready to work independent?
Request life, final expense and Medicare Advantage contracts at street level. Own your book. One contract is fine.
Start my contracting request →